Showing posts with label Journalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Journalism. Show all posts

28 August, 2017

The Monday Morning Quarterback

Kaepernick Supporters are Losing Touch with Reality


August 28, 2017
Peter Solari, Contributing Editor


Back on May 30th, The Monday Morning Quarterback published a piece exploring embattled quarterback Colin Kaepernick's activists advocates in the media, and the loss of their collective mind over his continuing status as an NFL free agent. Nearly three months later, not a whole lot has changed. Kaepernick remains unsigned, and the press is becoming more unhinged by the day.

Shannon Sharpe and Skip Bayless, hosts of "Undisputed" on Fox Sports 1, have been throwing a non-stop temper tantrum, clamoring for an NFL team to overpay for a mediocre (at best) backup quarterback, who has a terrible attitude and comes with a ton of baggage. However, despite the incessant whining coming from FS1, among others, NFL owners remain unmoved and Kaepernick is still unemployed. Maybe it's time for a new strategy, guys.

On Wednesday, we got our first taste of this new plan, when Derrick Johnson, interim president of the NAACP, "officially requested a formal meeting with NFL commissioner Roger Goodell to discuss NFL players and their ability to exercise their First Amendment rights." Here is an excerpt from Johnson's letter to the commissioner, as reported by James Barrett at The Daily Wire:

Last season, Mr. Kaepernick chose to exercise his First Amendment rights by protesting the inequitable treatment of people of color in America. By quietly taking a knee during the national anthem, he was able to shine a light on the many injustices, particularly, the disproportionate occurrences of police misconduct toward communities of color. As outlined in your office's public statement, this act of dissent is well within the National Football League's stated bylaws. Yet, as the NFL season quickly approaches, Mr. Kaepernick has spent an unprecedented amount of time as a free agent, and it is becoming increasingly apparent that this is no sheer coincidence. 

No player should be victimized and discriminated against because of his exercise of free speech -- to do so is in violation of his rights under the Constitution and the NFL's own regulations.
So apparently the new strategy is to make nonsensical arguments, and hope everyone is too confused to refute them, because Johnson's statement is littered with ignorance on several levels.

To suggest that Kaepernick has been punished for his speech is ludicrous considering the fact that he hasn't been fined, suspended, or disciplined in any way since he started his "protest" over a year ago. In fact, Goodell went to bat for Kaepernick after the saga started, saying, "Players have a platform, and it's his right to do that. We encourage them to be respectful and it's important for them to do that."

Furthermore, there are numerous players around the league who continue to kneel during the national anthem to this day. Much like Kaepernick, none of them have been disciplined for their political stand, so to allege that players are being punished for expressing themselves, is illogical. But what's more alarming is Johnson's misinterpretation of the First Amendment, which says:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

In other words, until and unless Congress passes a law oppressing Kaepernick's freedom of speech, and the President of the United States signs that legislation, this is in no way a First Amendment issue, whatsoever. Sorry about it.

It's also important for Johnson to understand that those same First Amendment protections that Kaepernick is afforded, are a two-way street. So while Kaepernick is free to express his opinions about America, NFL owners are allowed to express their opinions about him as well.


As a lawyer, Goodell should already understand all of this, but in reality, should a meeting between the commissioner and Johnson actually happen, all bets are off!

It would nice if the story ended here, but it's only just begun.

On Thursday, ESPN anchor Sage Steele told The Dan Patrick Show, "Owners in this league, they run a business, and they have a right to make the decision that they believe is best for their business — just like Colin Kaepernick has the right to express his opinion and do what’s best for him, for his brand, for his career. There’s repercussions to both."

Watch the full exchange below.



Of course, Steele's assesment is entirely correct, but that didn't stop Mike Florio's Pro Football Talk from tweeting these responses:



Equal employment opportunity (EEO) laws are regulations which prohibit employers from discriminating against employees or applicants based on race, religion, sex, age, sexual orientation, national origin, or disability. You may be asking yourself how exactly this applies to Kaepernick. In simple terms, it doesn't. And all Florio needs to do is take a quick gander around the NFL to see the flaws in his premise. 

Kaepernick is a 29-year old, biracial (black and white), straight, Christian male, who was born in America. There happen to be a plethora of American born, late 20's, straight, Christian males of various racial backgrounds in the NFL, so the notion that the league or its owners are, in any way, violating EEO laws is, for lack of a better term, stupid. Try again.

On Saturday, with the nation's attention on the "money fight" between Floyd Mayweather and Conor McGregor, CBS Sports college basketball analyst Seth Davis decided to get in on the action, tweeting:


In fairness, there was quite a bit of confusion surrounding this tweet, as many weren't sure what Davis even meant by this. Presumably, however, he was referring to the fact that Mayweather, who has a history of abusing women, is at the top of his sport, while Kaepernick, who has no criminal background to speak of, can't get a look. This reasoning makes sense on its surface, but Davis conveniently leaves out a couple of key points.

What really seems to have gotten lost in this saga is that when the 2016 season ended, Kaepernick did have a job. He was under contract with the San Francisco 49ers until he opted out of that deal this past March, under the delusion that teams would be knocking down his door for a chance to sign him. 49ers General Manager John Lynch did later say that the team would have released Kaepernick anyway, had he not opted out, but that is irrelevant. If I quit my job because I think my boss is going to fire me anyway, then I can't realistically blame my unemployment on anyone but myself. If I wait for my boss to fire me, then my circumstances are different, and I might have a legitimate beef.

Aside from that, what Davis really fails to grasp in his tweet, is how truly unfair it is to compare Mayweather and Kaepernick.

In the past, I've argued that if Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson was in the exact same boat as Kaepernick, then multiple NFL teams would be interested in his services and somebody would snatch him up quickly. That's because Wilson is an elite quarterback, and regardless of his past, people tend to be more forgiving to those who have something to offer in return.

In boxing, Mayweather is a bigger name than Wilson is in football, so it shouldn't be a mystery why one of the greatest boxers ever is getting paid, while a lousy QB with a ton of baggage and a style that doesn't fit in today's NFL, is begging for a backup role.

One thing Davis does get right in his tweet, is when he says "Because America." Both Mayweather's and Kaepernick's predicaments are results of the American system, but not for the reasons Davis believes.

In America, capitalism is king. If you've got a product that Americans crave (like you're the greatest boxer of your time, for example), then you can become rich beyond your wildest dreams. On the other hand, if you've got nothing to sell, then garnering interest and making money, will likely be difficult. And let's be honest: there aren't a whole lot of people dying to see Kaepernick play football.

As we inch closer to the opening of the 2017 season, the voices screaming in the media are only going to get louder until the league or one of its owners cave to Kaepernick's demands. But while their rationalizations get crazier by the day, the reality of the situation remains unchanged. There simply isn't enough incentive for a franchise to take on the headaches that come with signing a guy like Kaepernick to sit on the bench and hold a clipboard. Just ask Buffalo Bills running back LeSean McCoy.

Read More

26 June, 2017

The Monday Morning Quarterback

ESPN Rival FOX Sports will Reportedly Make Drastic Cuts of Their Own

[ PHOTO: THE PHILADELPHIA INQUIRER ]
ESPN recently underwent some major changes by laying off a ton of people, including major on-air personalities. It would seem that their biggest competitor in FOX Sports is making some moves of its own, but not quite on as grand a scale. SCOOP: Fox Sports is cutting its online writing staff to invest those resources in…
Read More

18 April, 2017

The Monday Morning Quarterback

Pirate Episode: Buccaneers Picked for Hard Knocks

[ PHOTO: TAMPA BAY TIMES ]
HBO training camp documentary series "Hard Knocks" will feature the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in August. The Buccaneers are expected to make a formal announcement about their featured role in the summer football staple on Wednesday. Episodes will begin airing in August. In 2016, the Los Angeles Rams were the focus of the series, which began in…
Read More

17 April, 2017

The Monday Morning Quarterback

Bengals CB Jones has Run-in with Reporter

[ PHOTO: NEW YORK POST ]
Cornerback Adam "Pacman" Jones of the Cincinnati Bengals Titans yelled at a reporter on Monday in his first meeting with the media since his arrest in January on multiple misdemeanor charges. Jones was incensed after he was asked by a local television reporter if he had anything to prove to Cincinnati's fans in the wake of…
Read More

07 April, 2017

The Monday Morning Quarterback

ESPN Downplays Replacement Of Sage Steele

[ PHOTO: FOX NEWS ]
The removal of ESPN anchor Sage Steele from the network's NBA coverage was being blown way out of proportion, according to the president of the sports-only cable TV station. Steele was replaced by another ESPN personality in an unexpected announcement Tuesday, but she was still staying with the network. "Sage has done a wonderful job for…
Read More

28 March, 2017

The Monday Morning Quarterback

After More than 20 Years, Another Tenured ESPN Anchor Could be Out of a Job

[PHOTO: SPORTING NEWS]
John Buccigross joined ESPN in 1996, and after more than 20 years of anchoring SportsCenter and penning the occasional column, the media personality could be out of a job, per Sporting News. ESPN will reportedly be trimming tens of millions of staff salary in the coming months as the worldwide leader continues to fight against cord…
Read More

07 March, 2017

The Monday Morning Quarterback

Latest Demoralizing Reports Out of ESPN Signal Just How Bad Things are at the Worldwide Leader

[PHOTO: NEW YORK POST]
ESPN’s business model has been under attack for quite some time and it is no secret that the worldwide leader has been forced to lay off many, many people as a result. However, yet another bombshell is reportedly set to drop, as Richard Deitsch of Sports Illustrated brings word of more cuts that will actually impact…
Read More

20 January, 2017

The Monday Morning Quarterback

NFL Writer in Hot Water After Sick Comparison of Trump Inauguration

Photo: USA Today
Politics bled over into the sports world on Friday, as the United States officially said goodbye to President Obama while welcoming the new President Trump. For one sports writer, though, it bled over a little too much. NFL writer Bart Hubbuch caused some commotion on social media during the inaugural ceremonies by comparing the day to…
Read More

16 December, 2016

The Monday Morning Quarterback

NBA Sideline Reporter Sager Dies at 65

Turner Sports NBA sideline reporter Craig Sager has died at the age of 65, the network announced Thursday. Sager waged a public battle with cancer over the past two years after originally being diagnosed with leukemia in 2014. The cancer went into remission after a bone marrow transplant but returned in March 2015. Sager, who was…
Read More

01 June, 2016

The Monday Morning Quarterback

The Oppression of Cops Singing in our Ballparks

Photo: Town Hall
June 1, 2016
Peter Solari
  

It's time for your daily dose of stupidity...

Have you ever gone to a ballgame or other sporting event where the national anthem was sung beforehand by a law enforcement officer or member of the military? I've seen it happen countless times in New York, especially since 9/11, and never once felt offended. Boy was I wrong! Or so says one columnist at ESPN.

Howard Bryant has a column in the June 6th issue of ESPN the Magazine, with the headline, "The Unspoken Truth." In it, Bryant derides what he calls "the staged patriotism" at professional sporting events, and asserts that these "authoritarian" practices, are unjustly harsh on black athletes in the aftermath of Ferguson and other high profile police shootings.

The piece isn't available online, and the only place I've ever seen ESPN the Magazine was the waiting room at my doctor's office. Newsbusters' Clay Waters, however, has seen it, and wrote about it in his May 28th column. According to Waters, Bryant wrote the following in the magazine: 
"Why don't more athletes speak out on behalf of their communities? Perhaps more of them would if there wasn't a chilling force looming over them...Policing is clearly one of the most divisive issues in the country - except in the sports arena, where the post-9/11 hero narrative has been so deeply embedded within its game-day fabric that policing is seen as clean, heroic, uncomplicated...Nobody seems to care much about this authoritarian shift at the ballpark, yet the media and the public are quick to demand accountability from players they consider insufficiently activist. They blame these black players for not speaking up on behalf of their communities, ignoring the smothering effect that staged patriotism and cops singing the national anthem in a time of Ferguson have on player expression. It's indirectly stifled, while the increasing police pageantry at games sends another clear message: The sentiments of the poor in Ferguson and Cleveland do not matter...While athletes are routinely criticized for 'not doing more,' it is conveniently ignored how deeply their employers have mobilized against the most powerless elements of their fan base."
You got that? Black players aren't free to express themselves because the white owners are honoring law enforcement and veterans at the games, and in doing so, are letting the black members of their communities know, they don't matter. Brilliant!

Bryant's whole argument lacks any semblance of logic. The NFL is one of the biggest offenders of this oppression, and they even got into some hot water over it. And, as Waters wrote for Newsbusters back in November, Bryant knows this. How then, is it possible, that the NFL is stifling the same athletes, in this case the St. Louis Rams, who are openly protesting the Ferguson police, on the field and in front of millions of fans watching on television? 

Back in 2014, after Michael Brown was shot and killed by Ferguson police, the phrase "hands up, don't shoot" became a rallying cry for anti-police protesters. At the time, the media was promoting a false narrative that Brown had his hands up and was surrendering when police shot him. In their week 13 game on November 30th of that year, several Rams players, who were being stifled by their white owners, mind you, entered the field with their hands in the air, in solidarity with the anti-police hooligans who were burning Ferguson to the ground. 

Video: TOMO News US

The entire "hands up, don't shoot narrative has been proven entirely false.

Bryant isn't a journalist, he's only a social justice warrior pretending to be one, he's part of a growing fad in America. He's also no stranger to ridiculing military and police. In his December 7th piece,  "Are You Ready for Some Patriotism?", Bryant wrote, 
"The influence of the military represents the most significant and uncomfortable change in sports in post-9/11 America. Significant because the game, on TV and at the stadium, has been awash in military overtones since the destruction of the World Trade Center, and uncomfortable because the root of the change has been an unstable, metastasizing of fear, nationalism, patriotism -- and especially commerce."
In his piece, Waters highlights a number of other instances where Bryant has been hostile to veterans, soldiers, and cops. In what is, perhaps, the most ironic thing Bryant has ever written, his June, 2013 column, "Sports and Patriotism," laments the following:
"The ballpark, in the time of two murky wars and a constant threat of international and domestic terrorism, has been for the last dozen years a place for patriotism. The industry that once avoided the complex world now embraces it, serving as the chief staging ground for expressions of patriotism, and has codified it into game-day identity.  
A dynamic that was supposed to be temporary has become permanent. The atmospheres of the games are no longer politically neutral but decidedly, often uncomfortably, nationalistic. The military flyovers, the pre-game inclusion of the armed forces, and the addition of 'God Bless America' to 'The Star Spangled Banner' are no longer spontaneous or reaction to a specific event, but fixtures."
Can not the many of the same things be said about ESPN? Wasn't ESPN established to cover sports and sports stories? Didn't it used to be a place you could go to escape from things like politics? Why then, has it evolved into a forum for left wing radicals like Bryant and Tony Kornheiser, to spew their liberal, nonsensical talking points 24/7. And why is it that they're free to do so, along as they tow the liberal line? Isn't it funny how anybody who veers from the narrative, is immediately fired? You can ask Curt Schilling all about that. He was let go for having the audacity to suggest that men shouldn't be allowed in the women's room. 
Read More

Contact Form

Name

Email *

Message *